Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers That Slap (and Sizzle)

I’ve cooked chicken so many times I could probably do it in my sleep.

Roasted, grilled, pan-fried, smoked, even once buried it under hot coals because I lost a bet.

But there’s something about buffalo chicken that just never gets old.

It’s messy.

It’s spicy.

It hits you in the mouth in the best possible way.

And when you stuff that chaos inside a roasted bell pepper, something borderline magical happens.

This recipe came from one of those weekday spirals.

You know the kind – fridge looking like a wasteland, just one lonely chicken breast staring back at me, half a bottle of Frank’s RedHot from God-knows-when, and four peppers I swear I bought for a salad that never happened.

I didn’t want to fry anything.

Didn’t feel like baking for hours.

But I needed something with a crunch and a kick… and just like that, this beauty was born.

Buffalo chicken stuffed peppers have that you’re-gonna-want-seconds vibe.

You get juicy, perfectly seasoned chickenwrapped in that buttery, tangy, spicy buffalo sauce, then tucked inside a pepper that somehow turns into the hero of the whole thing.

The pepper softens up, sure, but it still holds its shape.

It hugs the filling.

It gets roasted until the edges blister just enough.

Then comes the cheese.

Not too much, but enough to melt over the top like a warm blanket you didn’t know you needed.

I’ve made this for friends who claimed they hated spicy food.

I’ve served it to people who swear off bell peppers.

Every time, gone.

Like, plate-licking silence in the room kind of gone.

This isn’t some fancy restaurant dish pretending to be rustic.

It’s weeknight real, and it works whether you’ve got leftover rotisserie chicken or you’re starting from raw.

It’s also the kind of meal that makes you feel like you nailed dinner without losing your mind or wrecking your kitchen.

And if you think you’re too fancy for buffalo sauce?

Sit down.

You need this more than anyone.

What You’ll Need: Ingredients with Attitude

Pin

Serves 2 to 4, depending on hunger levels and how generous you’re feeling

This is one of those recipes where you don’t need to raid a specialty shop or read labels like you’re defusing a bomb. Just good basics, used right.

The Chicken

• 2 cups cooked, shredded chicken
  Rotisserie works like a charm… or use leftover grilled chicken. But if you’re starting from raw, just season well and cook it through before shredding.
  And yes, dark meat wins. It’s juicier and doesn’t dry out the second you turn around.

The Sauce

• 1/3 cup buffalo sauce
  Frank’s RedHot is the classic. Don’t mess with weird off-brand blends or anything that says “mild” unless you’re feeding toddlers or spice-averse in-laws.
• 2 tablespoons melted unsalted butter
  Because that buttery hit is what makes buffalo sauce taste like a wing shop, not just hot vinegar.

The Peppers

• 4 large bell peppers
  Any color works but let’s be honest… red and orange are sweeter and roast better. Green? Only if you like a bit of bite. Slice them in half lengthwise and clean out the seeds.

The Fillers and Flavor Lifters

• 1/2 cup cream cheese, softened
  Don’t skip this. It binds the filling and gives that rich, tangy backdrop that cuts the heat perfectly.
• 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
• 1/2 teaspoon onion powder
• Salt and pepper to taste
  Taste the mix before stuffing… always. It should pop in your mouth even before the oven does its job.

The Cheese Situation

• 3/4 cup shredded mozzarella or Monterey Jack
  You want meltability, not fancy. Save your aged cheddar for the cheese board.
• Optional: a sprinkle of blue cheese crumbles after baking
  Totally optional but if you like wings with blue cheese dressing, this hits that note in a smart, grown-up way.

On Top (Optional but Worth It)

• Fresh chopped parsley or green onion
  Adds color and freshness. Looks like you care, even if you’re wearing pajama pants and no one’s around to see it.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Preheat and Prep Your Peppers

Pin

Set your oven to 375°F. Not broil. Not 400. Just 375.

Trust me, it’s the sweet spot for roasted-but-not-burned.

Cut your bell peppers in half lengthwise, pull out the seeds and that white rib stuff. No need to over-scrape.

A spoon works better than your fingers, unless you’re into that messy chaos.

Lay the peppers in a baking dish, cut side up, like little boats waiting to be filled.

If they wobble?

Just trim the bottoms a tiny bit so they sit flat. No one wants a capsized dinner.

Step 2: Make It Saucy

Pin

Grab a bowl, toss in the shredded chicken, the buffalo sauce, and that buttery goodness you melted earlier.

Stir it like you mean it.

Now add in your softened cream cheese, garlic powder, onion powder, and a few pinches of salt and pepper.

Mix until it’s creamy, spicy, and fully coated. If it looks dry, add a splash more buffalo sauce.

If it tastes flat, it probably needs a pinch more salt.

Taste it. Always taste it.

If it doesn’t make you nod your head, fix it before it hits the oven.

Step 3: Stuff ‘Em Like You Mean It

Pin

Spoon the chicken mix into each pepper half.

Don’t pack it like you’re filling a suitcase.

Just firm and generous.

Top each one with shredded cheese, and don’t be shy.

Cheese strings matter.

That bubbly, melty top is half the reason we’re here.

Got extra filling?

Stuff it in a little ramekin and bake it beside the peppers.

Instant buffalo dip, no extra effort.

Step 4: Into the Oven They Go

Pin

Slide that baking dish into the oven.

Let them cook 25 to 30 minutes, uncovered.

You’re looking for bubbling cheese, softened peppers, and maybe a little golden color creeping around the edges.

If you’re into a crispier cheese top, throw on the broiler for the last 2 to 3 minutes… but don’t walk away.

The line between toasted and tragedy is short and cruel.

Step 5: Finishing Moves

Pin

Pull them out, let them sit for 5 minutes.

Just long enough to keep from burning your mouth while still getting that perfect cheese stretch.

Sprinkle on fresh parsley or green onion if you’re feeling it.

Hit the top with a few blue cheese crumbles if you’re on team funky.

And yeah, maybe a little extra buffalo drizzle.

Because why not?

Serving Game Strong

These peppers don’t need much else. One or two halves per person depending on the hunger level… or the size of the gym excuse. Serve with a side salad if you want to feel balanced. Or go all in with some crunchy fries or crispy roasted potatoes. No shame. This is comfort food with an actual purpose.

Need a dip? Ranch or blue cheese dressing on the side goes ridiculously well. Just a drizzle or straight dunk. Whatever makes your fork happy.

Make-Ahead Moves

You can prep these a few hours ahead. Stuff them, cover with foil and chill until it’s go-time. Then bake as normal. The cheese might need a few extra minutes to melt fully if they’re cold.

Leftovers? They reheat like champs. Microwave is fine. Oven is better. They hold their shape, they don’t get weird, and you’ll thank your past self at lunch the next day.

Flavor Bomb Extras

If you’re the kind who likes a twist, here’s where you go wild:

• Add crumbled bacon on top before baking. Instant crowd pleaser.
• Swap mozzarella for pepper jack if you want extra fire.
• Mix in some finely chopped celery for that buffalo wing bar vibe. Crunchy, cool, and lowkey genius.

One Last Bite (The Real Talk)

Pin

I’ve made a lot of things with chicken… some glorious, some questionable.

But these buffalo chicken stuffed peppers?

They land every single time.

They’ve got that heat, that creaminess, the pop from the pepper, and a pull of cheese that makes you pause mid-chew like, wait, did I just nail that?

And let’s be honest.

Sometimes dinner feels like a chore.

A thing you check off.

But this one?

It makes you feel like a kitchen genius without the mess or the stress.

You don’t need six pots, a degree from culinary school or a playlist of French jazz to make it work.

Just good chicken, solid sauce, and a pepper that holds its own.

Here’s my one grandma-style nudge before you go… don’t skip the butter in the buffalo sauce.

That’s not a garnish. It’s the soul.

Without it, you’ve just got hot chicken.

And you deserve better than hot chicken pretending to be something else.

So make it. Eat it. Watch it disappear.
And if someone asks you for the recipe, just give them a wink and say, “it’s in the peppers.”